Book Reviews by Jones
Thursday, September 23, 2010
‘The Five Dysfunctions of a Team (Manga Edition): An Illustrated Leadership Fable’ by Patrick Lencioni
It is safe to say that I wouldn’t have read this book if it weren’t in graphic novel form. Furthermore, I wouldn’t have read this graphic novel if it weren’t something curriculum-related that I purchased for our library. Lencioni’s story is about a business with disorganized unsuccessful leadership that hires a new CEO to turn the company around. Several meetings take place in which she confronts the tension of the existing management and attempts to teach them to work together effectively.
The end of this book gives specific advice for carrying out the team reformation that the author recommends. It’s difficult to say whether this book would be helpful to me if I were actually in a team leadership position. Most of the advice makes sense and is clearly explained. But is the advice too simple? It seems like some of the things discussed may be obvious, but maybe this is the problem – management techniques that work are so deceptively simple that they get overlooked.
As I’m sure some are aware, Lencioni has written The Five Dysfunctions of a Team (non-Manga edition), on which this edition is based. I can’t comment on how similar the content is, not having read the original. However, as a person who reads very little in the way of business management books, I can say that this is a tolerably entertaining, quick and painless read.
Wednesday, September 22, 2010
‘Forever…’ By Judy Blume
If my daughter were just a few years older she would be reading this book right now. As it is, we’ll have to wait a few more years. Forever… is a story about teenage relationships and adolescent sexuality. The main character, Kath, meets Michael at a party and they begin dating. As their relationship progresses they naturally become physically intimate as well. This book is an entertaining and honest story that can be easily enjoyed by many, not just the target audience.
There are many books that criminalize teenage sexuality; Judy Blume is accepting. Some authors would have punished the sexually active protagonist with pregnancy, illness or parental wrath, but this is not the case with Blume’s classic. Written in 1975, Forever… gives a teen perspective on many sexual issues that are important to adolescents: virginity, contraception, peer pressure, abortion, teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Teens (and others) who read this book will understand that Kath is an average teen who is learning about herself and her body in a healthy way. Even though they seek to protect her, her parents don’t make her ashamed of her sexuality, which is another refreshing departure from the norm. So even though nothing lasts forever (especially teen love), this book’s relevancy is likely to last for a very long time.
‘Club Dead’ By Charlaine Harris
Club Dead is the third book of Sookie Stackhouse’s vampire adventures. The book begins with Bill acting strangely distant then disappearing. Eric asks Sookie to travel to Jackson, Mississippi and use her abilities to figure out what might have happened. This trip involves more encounters with werewolves and vampires as well as more description of the vampire power structure that has been alluded to in previous books.
As I get further along in the Sookie Stackhouse series I keep finding reasons to dislike Bill. Given that, one of the best things about this book is the fact that Bill has a very small role and several other (better) male characters are developed. Although Sookie leaves much to be desired from a feminist perspective, her independence and determination are a welcome departure from other popular vampire stories (Twilight, anyone?). Rather than being totally dependent on the men who are romantically interested in her, Sookie looks out for herself and isn’t afraid to be without male companionship. Though we could certainly do better as far as female role models are concerned, we could also be doing much, much worse.
Monday, September 20, 2010
'Life of Pi' by Yann Martel
It feels that many people will have already read the novel Life of Pi, so this review may not be terribly helpful to those people. But I have read this book recently and enjoyed it thoroughly, so there will be a review anyway. Life of Pi is the story of a teenage boy, Pi Patel, who is travelling with his family from Asia to North America when the ship sinks. The ship had also been transporting many of the family’s zoo animals, and four of these animals, a zebra, an orangutan, a hyena and a Bengal tiger, end up on a lifeboat with Pi. After a short time, Pi and the tiger are the only two remaining. Life of Pi is a survival story combined with the unusual element of fear, admiration and love of the Bengal tiger, Robert Parker.
Pi is a very religious boy and though the book is not heavy-handed in this respect, there is frequent evidence of his faith throughout. When looked at in these terms, Pi’s love and fear of Richard Parker elevates the tiger to a deity-like status. By staying by his side during his darkest time, the tiger saves Pi from desperation and certain death. If Martel had written a novel about a shipwreck survivor that saved himself through his own faith in god, this wouldn’t have been an unusual book at all; it is the transfer of religious love to a living being that makes the book uncommonly endearing.
All in all, a wonderful book with a bittersweet ending – C.S. Lewis would have been proud.
Thursday, September 16, 2010
‘A Thousand Acres’ By Jane Smiley
In A Thousand Acres, Smiley rewrites Shakespeare’s King Lear setting the story on a 1970’s Iowa farm. An aging father decides to pass his farm on to his three daughters, but only the two daughters who live on the farm accept the offer. The novel tells the story of the family’s ensuing rift and the changes in the relationships of all involved. Even though the setting and circumstances are very different than the play from which it was derived, the story remains remarkably similar.
Even though I have finished this book, I can’t really decide how I feel about it. One reason I feel ambiguous towards A Thousand Acres is the fact that I can’t figure out exactly what Smiley wants to say, if anything. The book seems like it could be feminist, environmentalist, progressive and nostalgic; and I agree with many of the things that Smiley talks about. There is an interesting scene in which the narrator, Ginny, talks to the proprietor of the local antiques store and says something along the lines of “why would anyone want to give up such a treasure?” Maybe that is the whole point of the story: letting go of old things, not holding on to old things that you’re supposed to want just for the sake of holding on. When the rest of the book was over, I was really just left with an anticlimactic sense that nothing matters at all and the point of life is just to get it over with as quickly as possible. But I guess King Lear (and any rewrites) wouldn’t be a tragedy if it were uplifting.
‘Living Dead in Dallas’ By Charlaine Harris
As many True Blood fans may (or may not) know, Living Dead in Dallas is the second volume in the Sookie Stackhouse series by Charlaine Harris. In this book Sookie’s relationship with Bill continues and the two of them are ordered to go to Dallas to investigate the disappearance of a vampire in that city. Sookie’s job is to use her telepathic ability to try to discover who was involved in the vampire’s disappearance.
The series grows increasingly strange as more and more supernatural elements are introduced: more telepaths and shape-shifters, adding werewolves and maenads. But to be perfectly honest, I think that the television show probably becomes much more far-fetched than the book. This is the draw of the Sookie Stackhouse franchise; the campy fantasy is addicting. Wouldn’t we be disappointed if it weren’t a little ridiculous?
Monday, September 13, 2010
‘Dance of Death’ by Francine Pascal
It should be painfully obvious by now that I really enjoy reading old Sweet Valley High books. Unfortunately, the local public library doesn’t both keeping these dated teen books on the shelves anymore as updated books for teen girls have become popular lately. Though Dance of Death was enjoyable, it isn’t a stand alone book and ends in a cliffhanger. If the library had the next book in the series this wouldn’t be a problem. Jessica and Enid are competing for the love of the mysterious Jonathan who recently moved to Sweet Valley and lives by himself in a crumbling mansion (wtf?). Meanwhile, Elizabeth has problems of her own as her summer fling comes to California and attempts to win her from longtime boyfriend Todd Wilkins.
This story seems to be fairly typical of Sweet Valley because it includes Todd/Elizabeth relationship drama and Jessica falling for a somewhat dodgy character. Of course, the best Sweet Valley books also include supernatural elements and Dance of Death won’t disappoint readers in this respect either (spoiler alert: A Vampire, spooky!). On a side note, it amazes me that just about every Sweet Valley book includes Elizabeth cheating on Todd Wilkins, and Todd seems to be thickheaded enough to keep returning to her. But that seems to be just one of the many things that make Sweet Valley so good, no matter how many murders and betrayals take place, it will be mostly back to normal within a couple hundred pages.